I just cannot get a clear grip on filtering. Obviously Hippie you do not think it degrades your wine's flavor but I have read so much pro and con there just seems to be no clear cut answer.
I don't know of any cons to proper filtering. I can think of several pros. What are some of the cons you have read? There are alot of myths floating around. Remember I said "proper filtering". A taste or odor molecule is too small to be filtered out using anything that is available to us, or anything else I have read of. Unimaginable. So, forget all that stuff you have read elsewhere on the WWW about filtering out taste, it is nonsense. Some color of red wines can be filtered out using the #3 sterile filters, but that would not be proper filtering. The #3 sterile filters are not meant for filtering red wines. Filtering will 'shock' the wine, much the same as bottling does. Any aggressive action on the wine 'shocks' it. The flavor and bouquet will return with time. There is no real need to ever filter a wine, as far as homewinemaking goes. You rack off sediment while bulk aging and then bottle when stable and clear. A dusting of sediment in aged wine bottles is not a fault, and is very common is most red commercial wines.Noone shouldever think they must filter their wines.
Questions, comments, and arguments very much welcome!
Obviously filtering has produced a beatuiful wine for you in this case. I want to sample it just so I can feel the beauty of it in my mouth!
But like you said, there's no reason in the world that people "have" to filter to get a fabulous wine. I've had several really good commercial reds with a touch of sediment at the end of the bottle and I can't see that it's removal would have made the wine any better. We've never filtered and no one has refused our wines yet!