Man, What a great thread!
Soapbox is now at my feet...
My inventory WAS about 2,500 bottles. I say WAS for a reason..
I learned the hard way that building inventory is wonderful, but only up to a point. Many wines can only last just so long. Corks, too can only last so long.
I had a special occasion recently and opened a bottle of my 1993 cabernet. This was a wine that (at the time) was truly worthy of aging. The color was beautiful, the clarity was good, but the flavor had sadly faded. The wine was like colored water. I opened three other bottles and they were all the same. The wine was simply not worth drinking anymore.
When I think of how wonderful the wine was, and that I could have enjoyed it at the time, I began to question my whole approach to inventory.
I took a weekend and tasted through all of my wines that were older than 10 years. Two were still in excellent condition, but many were either fading or completely faded. I ended (about 2 months ago) having an "old vintage" party with about 20 good friends. With 2 exceptions (1998 merlot and 1999 san gio), all wines tagged as over 10 years is up for grabs (for drinking first, then for taking home). The only rule was this.. At some point, clean and return the bottles to me.
So I basically had a good time liquidating my old stock. On some of the bins, I tagged "Please leave me 12" for the wines that were still very drinkable. Over all, I managed to lighten my inventory by some 700 bottles. We drank about 40, dumped about 100, and folks took home the rest.
Sorry (again) for the long story. This all went down very recently and I felt that it would be good to share.
So in summary..
- Seeing old wines go past their prime is much like a father's lament over not spending enough time with his kids... "Oh, the good times we should have had (but never did)".
- Aging wine is all well and good, but there is an optimal age for any wine. Try not to hang on to too much for too long.
- Never age an inferior wine. You will only be taking up space as there will ALWAYS be something better to drink. I held on to 6 cases of 1998 white burgundy (YUK!) and NEVER opened a single bottle. It is nice to have that space for better things.