geocorn said:
The grape packs are varietal specific and need to be to support the flavor as you indicated. This is not to say it can't be done. It just that you will produce a wine with different characteristics than by just using the kit.
The grape pack is a relatively new item, especially the WE pack since it is more than just grape skins, seeds, stems and nails. How the grape pack is used by WE over the next several years is anyone'e guess, but I would be surprised if they became available as an upgrade. The grape pack would probably increase the price of a VR to that of a selection kit, so do you want more fresh juice or the skins. I think the fresh juice would be more important up to a certain level, then the grape pack. Now you have a crushendo.
By the way, WE recommends against re-using the grape skins. They say they are used up during the first 7 days of primary.
George, Wine Expert must be varietal specific. I believe thedata I read was in reference to Cellar Craft grape packs. If I remember right, the data came from the manufacturer in communications with a customer.It referred to all of theirkits using the same grape pack. I am not saying this is the gospel but I just remember reading this information when I made this brand specific kit. You know the Internet, it never provides false information either!
Further information I remember of this brand was the Cellar CraftAmarone kit has like some type of Raisin pack added to the generic grape pack resulting in a 10 pound grape pack as opposed to a 7 pound pack (don't hold me to the weights, I am going my a cloudy memory). Guess I should of been more specific in my babbling.I will scrounge around and see if I still have the info saved somewhere.
After hearing Tim G. speak, I have no doubt that the Wine Expert kits are varietal specific. Sounds like they are "super anal", which is good. In fact it's great as we get a super product. I was quite impressed with the science they put into their manufacturing. I wish I could find similar information as to the manufacturing process for the other companies so we could compare apples to apples or I guess should say Cabernet's to Cabernet's!
We all know the superior product that WE makes. I still believe other companies make a quality product as well. I buy WE cause thats what George sells. I am more than pleased. I guess I post the information for those that may not buy from George. I know you say who wouldn't but personally I hope winemakers that may buy from their local brew shops will still utilize this forum to share knowledge as well as make new friends. Their local shops may sell a different brand. I read about numerous brands such as the Cellar Craft, RJ Espagnol's, Herron Bay and a few others I just can't spell.
I am not advocating a switch to other brands. I just feel everyone deserves a fair shot before wedecimate them.
If a particular brand trips your trigger, by all means make it and enjoy it no matter where it came from. Just remember to factor in customer service along with the quality factor. They go hand in hand. But hey, we have that covered here don't we!
Smurfe