@bstnh1 Good question, ,,, the human right is to be treated fairly.
the job of government is to do actions for the common good, frequently this is health (ex covid), and defense, and regulations, and improving the economic well being of all.
A century ago it was considered common good to find a cure for polio, for cholera, for small pox, , , we have stories as typhoid Mary who was confined against her will because she was an asymptomatic super spreader. The court decided that she could be confined for the common good even though she had not committed a crime, ,,, was typhoid Mary treated fairly? ,,, Today we have a similar outbreak in covid. asymptomatic people are spreading it and some unfortunates then get sick, with about 2% developing lasting lung damage and about 1% of symptomatic folks get to die. What is fair? the majority will live, ,,,, reduce the risk for all with masks/ capacity limits/ etc ,,, and why has our neighbor’s health become a tribal issue? apparently not enough have died yet and we have lost the memory of iron lungs/ polio.
I laugh that monoclonal antibodies were used a month ago to treat the leader with covid. Science took fetal stem cells and manipulated genetics to make the cocktail,,,, Was this fair? the leader did not earn that health care (and also he's against the health care which produced the fetal cells which turned into new technology to allow him recover symptom free), ,,, and so far you and I are not offered this technology, at any price. Good question above, ,, is health care a right, better question, what would be fair if it were your kid?
The Japanese system is designed so the lowest paid worker and highest paid are separated by 70x. The US is a lot farther apart, I see numbers in the high 200s every year. With covid we are calling lots of bottom wage workers “essential”, really? if they really are/ were essential then why not treat the bottom more equally? ,,,, did the CEO get paid health care and transportation? probably, ,,, do we as a people find it important that all are treated fairly? (especially the next generation)
OPINION; no the government should not and frankly can not give everyone everything, work is good and individuals who have stupid behavior patterns should not have them rewarded ,,, HOWEVER the rules should be established so that all are treated fairly, AND especially that the kids all have a chance to be productive and smart and honest and lead happy lives, kinda treated like we would want ourselves and our grandkids to be treated.
I worked in research which only existed because we as a society have enough resources that we can burn through our surplus and never go hungry, we are a rich species! I have also seen the other side, ,,, I was willing to be a single parent of a special needs kid, was willing to be the 24 hour care giver, and on food stamps, and on mom care etc ,,,, because I love my kid. What would you want if it were you? what is the common good if it is you?
We as a species have developed monoclonal antibodies, electricity, clothing, wine, basically everything today, , , , , only because we have worked together for the common good
Health care a human right???? Well, we need clothing, housing, transportation, food, personal care items and a whole lot more. Should we make those "human rights" too?? It amazes me how many people think the government should provide everything they need while they sit back and say "gimme more".