No, it can't be. The math doesn't add up.I believe the difference in these kits is the amount of juice supplied with each one.
The short answer is "no".My question is, "Do both kits contain the same juice?"
I'm not sure why you say that? Their ingredients list has no "juice" in the list for the heavy body Merlot kit:The 16 liter heavy body kit contains juice as well as concentrate, but we don't know if the concentrate is the same as the 5.2 liter kit.
For my last reply, I considered the situation, made rough calculations in my head, and came to a logical conclusion. For this one? I developed a couple of basic formulas.I'm not sure why you say that? Their ingredients list has no "juice" in the list for the heavy body Merlot kit:
Not sure if my point came through but some producers hide the addition of water in the word "juice concentrate", both will be labelled as "juice concentrate" both being made from the SAME 85 brix concentrate to use your example:My math may be off a bit, but regardless there is a huge difference between the brix in each bag. The most obvious explanations are the concentrates are different, the larger bag contains juice (well, a lot more juice), or both. If someone has a different explanation, I'd love to hear it.
I was going to reply to this point, but got caught up in my calculations and forgot.Not sure if my point came through but some producers hide the addition of water in the word "juice concentrate", both will be labelled as "juice concentrate" both being made from the SAME 85 brix concentrate to use your example:
My calculations should be taken with several grains of salt!An another remark here; all our calculations above should be taken with a grain of salt as they use "liquid invert sugar " in their formulations to boost brix.
Oh, I was discussing low end kits, perhaps a mistake. I thought wine lovers was low ends kits. I wasn't including the likes of WE, that I'm sure have juice in their premium kits.If concentrate-only made the best wine, all kits would be 5 liter kits. Juice is added to concentrates to improve quality, e.g., make better wine, although the addition increases cost and weight. The larger the juice/concentrate bag, supposedly the higher the quality of the resulting wine along with a higher price.
Agreed!There's little likelihood we'll get a real answer, and on my part it's just conjecture. However, this is a fun discussion regardless of which theory (if any) is correct. It's got us thinking about the product we are buying.
I wondered why I would pay for Sun Maid organic raisins when cheaper raisins were available for a third the price. Again, JoesWine came through. The result in several cheap reds was spectacular. As an added bonus, the Sun Maid raisins made my Scottish scones really jump.Sun maid brand is what you should use read tweaking cheap wine kits for details and why .
Make a fresh batch of Strawberry fpac and add it to the primary, nice additionI wondered why I would pay for Sun Maid organic raisins when cheaper raisins were available for a third the price. Again, JoesWine came through. The result in several cheap reds was spectacular. As an added bonus, the Sun Maid raisins made my Scottish scones really jump.
Any thought on what I can add to a cheap White Zinfandel from Costco? It's one of those 60 bottle kits for $109. I've had pretty good results by just shorting the water but I'd like to bump it up a notch.
Enter your email address to join: