I did not have the beginning sg only the one taken at day 2 of primary in which case the Pineapple was at a 1.040 and the Strawberry was sitting at 1.105 sg.
Something seems off. If you add 2 lbs of sugar to 1 gallon of water, you get a SG of ~1.080. If you took your reading on day 2, my guess is that little fermentation would have happened. I doubt you could have knocked off 0.040 after just 2 days, but I could be wrong. How active/foamy/bubbly was it on day 2?