I don't always agree with the reviewers but its always nice to have some conformation on something you have not tasted. Most of my wines are purchased via list allocation so they have not been rated formally when I get them. A few do sometimes have barrel tastings from RP as a guide but they are done when a wine is usually only about 12-18 months old and still in its infancy so again, may or may not hold up. Can't always trust it.