Took suggestions from the group, but Ohio Bob may be correct that carboy is permanently etched. Tried 'chlorine free' oxyclean with the 'mark II' carboy pump cleaner. Ran pump for 45 minutes with a steady stream of cleaner rolling down the sides of the carboy. Used my drill mounted rotating paddle brush and doubled down my scrubbing effort. No luck. As a last resort, I moved the carboy upstairs away from my wine making area and tools and let it soak with bleach for 48 hours. I was very careful not to use any of my tools while trying the bleach far away from my winemaking area. Scrubbed by hand with a sacrificial brush. Didn't work. Man that was a stubborn stain. The carboy is probably fine to use, but its the only one in my fleet with a cloudy haze. I'll probably store it as a backup to my backup. Thanks for the input and suggestions.