I'm wanting to start my first batch, but the daily squeezing of the fruit bag is holding me back. If i squeeze the thawed fruit up front and just punch it down daily, how would that affect the outcome?
You've had lots of varying opinions; here's mine.
@dangerdave originally developed his process, I believe, as a way to
minimize the effort, and
maximize the extraction of color and flavor. I think if you did a side-by-side comparison, with 1 lb of fruit per gallon, between using the "presser" method, and just punching it down, you would find a noticeable difference. I put the fruit in a knee-high nylon stocking (thanks for that tip, Dave), use nitrile gloves (easy to sanitize, and keeps my hands clean), and just wring the stocking out like a dish cloth, into the primary. No mess. It's pretty dry when I set it into a sanitized bowl. Out of curiosity, I weighed it every time, and every time it weighed substantially less and felt noticeably smaller. I'm not sure why
@Bossbaby says don't wring the guts out of it, but I wring the guts out of mine. Funny story: the first batches I made using the cheapest dollar-store knee-highs I could find. At $0.25 each, they were awesome. For my last batch, dollar-stores were closed due to COVID, and I had to purchase expensive ones at the grocery store for more than ten times the price. After 2 or 3 presses, those expensive ones ran, and I had to double them up to prevent the berries from hemorrhaging into my must! I'm sticking with the cheap ones from now on.
Having said all that, another way of getting more color and flavor from the fruit into your wine is to simply add more fruit. I'm starting to use my own fruit. I live in the city. The amount of fruit I get from my (and my neighbor's) trees is very limited. I would rather have twice as much wine from the same amount of fruit, so I squeeze every last drop of goodness that I possibly can from it.