I don't think it matters, I started with the handle cause everyone else was using one. But I'm thinking if I mess up one of my wines everyone will know, but only here and not reminded about it all the other places I go. But how else will I know if I messed up. I'm here to get help in my new hobby. And I was told that it wasn't that expensive to start or do (my neighbor) but I got to have all the toys. Just like I have dozens of 12' tape measures and paint scrapers (use to be a carpenter, electrician and plumber but needed insurance). Now I've got a lot of those bottle openers you keep in your pocket. Many years ago, my brother and his wife gave us a very nice wine bottle opener. I said at that time (not to them) I'll never use this thing. I'm thinking it'll be warn out by the end of the year.