ANYONE HAVE GOOD RESULTS WITH THESE KITS OR BAD???
Just joined the forum. I have made many of these kits as we have lots of house parties and lots of friends over for many bottles of wine. It was costing me too much to buy store bought, so I went back to wine making. I used to make about 15-20 years ago but stopped with wine and just made beer as the taste of wine kits was not that great. Times have changed as the new wine kits are very good today.
I have made approximately 20 fontana kits in the last couple of years. You are certainly doing the right things by tweaking as the 6 gal kits come out somewhat thin. I have done the 6 to 5 gal on a few kits, but the end product did not suit my taste buds. Even after bulk aging 6mos and 6mos in bottle, the end product came out hot with an alcohol burn at the forefront that overwhelmed the fruit tastes. I need to try another bottle and see if it has mellowed further. I make the standard 6 gal but add oak, raisins, currants, sugar to increase alcohol and sometimes after fermentation to sweeten a little. I do not go as high on ABV as you and usually final product is in the 12-13% in finished product. My opinion on value based on available kits from amazon are:
Reds
Merlot: straight out winner. good flavor after 6mos and better at 1 year. After tweaks compares to $10 bottle of table wine or maybe a $15 depending on the tweaks.
Malbec: worth the kit, but not great. Maybe $5-7. I have made this both medium and heavy oak, and the heavy oak is better, but you need to really like oak flavor
Cab Sauv: Not great IMHO. Will make a $5 bottle finished. Trying again currently with a kit in primary for a neighbor who wanted a cheap cab that is better than the harris teeter oak something brand he was buying for large parties. He said anything was better than what he was buying and after tasting I agree.
Shiraz: good value with an average taste and end product. Only made one kit
Pinot Noir: Have not made as I was scared of a $40 kit and skeptical that I could make a decent wine from this kit
White:
Chardonnay: Good kit for an average bottle. Have done medium to heavy oak and both are good. Does have a slight KT even after a year in the bottle. I do a lot of these kits as we have lots of pool parties. The best of the fontana whites.
Pinot Grigio: Disappointing on my end. My wife's favorite wine and I just cannot get this wine kit dry enough and fruity enough for her. I have made 5-6 kits and nothing I do seems to help. Any suggestions will be appreciated. Wife and friends still drink it though and I need to start a new kit in the next month. I usually make one of these kits for parties and another more expensive kit for the wife and close friends.
They also have higher end kits and I have an Amarone in secondary. It was $90 and I had an amazon gift cert so I said what the heck. I have a RJS WS amarone that I am starting this week to compare as they age that was a Christmas gift. Would rather have had the CC kit, but gifts are gifts.
Let us know your opinion of kits as they age.