A Tale of Two Wine Kits:
I decided to open two bottles tonight. When I met up with @jgmann67 and @ceeaton at Harford Vineyard back in October, we exchanged quite a few bottles. Jim gave me one of his Eclipse SLD Merlots, which I've also made. So I opened up one of mine and one of his to compare.
Color: Both were virtually identical, which surprised me a little bit. Mine had 3 months of barrel time and I thought that might serve to darken it up a bit. Apparently not.
On the nose: Jim's had notes of blueberry, raspberry, cocoa and if I really took a deep whiff, a hint of anise. Mine was a little flat, showing some raspberry and blueberry, but also a very slight metallic note.
Taste: Jim's was consistent with the nose and has a good amount of oak that comes through. Mine is very similar, though the oak is way in the background - you have to be looking for it. I recall when making this that there was a lot of oak flavor early on and I even held back on some of it. My early notes refer to a very oaky wine for a Merlot, but that is gone. Both of these are pretty enjoyable, but different in the oak department. Goes to show that even with a kit, you can produce unique results.
Okay, its been 20 minutes or so since I poured these glasses. There are caramel and vanilla notes really coming out on both of these now. With the fruit, its quite good. In some ways, making me think of dessert, though they are definitely dry wines. Jim's is showing just a little more fruit, while mine is showing more tannin/bite. Still both quite enjoyable, though a little different. I think that may be the age talking - mine was started in Aug, 2014, while I think Jim's was sometime in 2015. Again, both quite enjoyable, but it is fun noting the differences.