Wine Kit suggestions.

[wyntheef]

Wine Kit review resource.

I saw another new thread today asking for kit recommendations. I didn't want to hijack the thread, but realized the same basic question is asked (and answered) repeatedly.

As often as kit suggestions are asked for on the forum, I thought maybe we could have a kit review spread sheet, listing individual kits, each having their own qualities rated as percieved by those who had made them previously.

For example, if you had done a W.E. Selection Cab kit, you would be able to give a 1-5 star rating (like on eebaey) for different aspects of the kit, and the spreadsheet would dynamically update to reflect the new information.
It could list such things as dry/sweet scale, maybe an overall rating based on general satisfaction, and whatever else might seem relevant.


Thoughts?

 

[Dugger]

Well, I like the idea. Even though our individual tastes will vary, if enough people input data the results should be fairly representative, and this could be a handy tool for anyone wanting to try a different kit. Many people tweak kits and this could cause some skewing - not sure how significant this would be.
Sounds like a bit of work for someone to set up, though.

 

[wyntheef]

I'm going to talk to some friends that work with spreadsheets to see if they'd be willing to put something together.

 

[wyntheef]

I'm going to talk to some friends that work with spreadsheets to see if they'd be willing to put something together.

After a few conversations about this idea, it appears to be much more difficult than I knew. Got a few ideas to kick around though, so I'll see what I can come up with.