CabSauv
Exp Drinker/Junior Vintner
- Joined
- Mar 21, 2017
- Messages
- 172
- Reaction score
- 126
Hey Doug,
I started last summer the same way way you are now, so I'll throw in my experience.
I did a WE World Vineyard Trinity Red first to learn on. It had a weird smell to me, like salami, even in the juice before fermenting, but it was a good one to make mistakes on. Next, I tried a 10L with skins kit, CC Sterling Malbec, and it was a step up from the Trinity, but still meh, like a discount house wine. Similar to you, they were missing something, but in order to understand the hobby, I needed to know how the different levels tasted. Last summer, I also started a premium kit, RJS En Primeur Super Tuscan, 16L with skins. It was magnitudes better than the 10L kits throughout the entire process - it smelled better, it tasted better, and the only thing it was missing to me was a bit of tannin, but that's a personal taste thing.
So where I'm going with this: if you're a wine snob, jump up to the 16L/18L with skins kits. They are absolutely worth it, and if you watch for sale prices, they're $30 more for significantly better taste. I didn't think of myself as a wine snob until I was underwhelmed by the Trinity and Malbec wines. In Jan, I started a WE Eclipse Lodi Cab and CC Showcase Carmenere; they're bulk aging right now, and they're great! I'd even be so bold to say that they're currently comparable to the $10-15 commercial bottles we drink. I think the Cab still has a little gas, which I'll need to deal with before bottling, but the Carmenere is absolutely fantastic. The CC Showcase instructions say 10 days in primary on skins, and I think it made a huge difference in the flavor and degassing, so I'll continue that method on future kits.
The Trinity and Malbec are about 10 months old now, and I don't think they're any better than they were at 4 months old. But I told hubby we're not allowed to put the premium kits into rotation until we finish them off, otherwise we'll never go back to them. So if you're looking to satiate your inner snob, I recommend the premium skins kits with a 10-day primary. It's worth it.
I look forward to hearing how your second kit with fruit turns out. Keep us posted!
That's excellent information, it sounds like we are in the same boat and so is mainshipfred who also posted above. That's the route I was leaning towards going, specifically an RJS kit. Like the name says, I'm really a big fan of cabernet and the dry reds so I'll look at my options and try something bigger for my next batch. I just wish I could find a place that sells them so I can see the kits in person. Not that I wouldn't buy online but considering the price and shipping, a wine kit isn't the same as a widget from Amazon and I just like to see the product. Anyone have any recommendations for best places to buy online if that's the route I end up taking?