First Batch of Wine...at scale-ish - and a few questions

Winemaking Talk - Winemaking Forum

Help Support Winemaking Talk - Winemaking Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Joined
Aug 12, 2024
Messages
16
Reaction score
12
Location
Knoxville, Iowa
We took over this vineyard earlier this year, and have been learning everything we can as fast as we can. The local winery we thought was going to buy our La Crescent ended up having too much already. And while we found some other buyers, we were going to lose money on the deal getting the grapes transported. Since we'd planned to start making and selling wine next year anyway, we decided to keep the grapes for ourselves and make this our trial run. We figured this would be a good way to get one under our belt, learn, make the mistakes, and experiment without the pressure of having to please a consumer. I ordered a tank, crusher, small press, etc. But it took some time to get them shipped, and the grapes sat on the vine too long. We lost a lot of fruit to shelling, but it ended up being as much as we could handle anyway.

Our harvesters were slow, and I was gathering and transporting all the bins in our Gator. At about 3pm, they were gone, we were tired, and we had about a ton of grapes sitting in the empty "winery" garage. All the winery equipment was still sitting at the foot of the garage wrapped up on pallets. But by about 9pm, we were finally crushing and pressing. I ended up doing most of that, because my wife was busy sorting through trying to cull the bad stuff that came in. At 2:30am, we were pretty delirious, and decided to get some sleep. I sprayed the bins with SO2 to try to protect them overnight. Fortunately, it got down to about 50 degrees that night, so I think that helped keep them fresh enough. We finished up by early the next evening, and had about 100 gallons in the 525L tank, plus 15 gallons that I froze in corny kegs to experiment with later in beer/wine hybrids. We learned a LOT- the hard way- about how logistics will need to work next time.

The grapes had sat so long on the vine, they were at 24.5-25 brix. I'd read that La Crescent can get very acidic, and our juice was at 3.07 pH and about 12 TA. SO2 levels were about 35, since I was adding it to the must during the crush. After one failed attempt to get fermentation started, I diluted the must to 23.5 brix/1.010 SG, and got it going on the second try with 71B, which is supposed to lower acidity during fermentation. It took off big, and had a very vigorous primary. It's been in a closed tank with an airlock, and I recirculated the must every day until it got down to 1.005 SG.

Now three weeks later, primary has finally ended. A few burps still pop up from time to time, but it is DRY - .992 SG. We like wine to be dry, so I'm fine with that. TA came down to about 10.5, and pH is up to 3.2. I don't taste/smell any burnt matches or eggs, so I think it's still clean. But being so dry and so acidic, it's abrasively tart, almost bitter.

We want to experiment, so we know the best route for next year. I want to pull off a few portions and condition them separately in smaller vessels.

These are the possible variations for conditioning we are looking at:

1. Malolactic to mellow the acid and give it some complexity. Not usually used with a grape like La Crescent, but why not?
2. K carbonate to lower acidity, with the wine conditioned off the lees
3. K carbonate to lower acidity, with the wine recirculated on the lees
4. One of the above, eventually adding hop oil and carbonation. Another winery in the area has done this, and we really liked the results.

So, questions...

1. With the acidity so high to begin with, should I have added K carb before fermentation? I had one winemaker friend tell me to always wait until after, and another later tell me to always add it before.
2. I dumped the initial sediment from the must out before fermentation. In brewing, we'd call it a trub dump. Now that primary is over, do I need to dump the yeast sediment ASAP, or keep the wine on it? I'm confused about that.
3. Do you think any of the options above for experimentation are a waste of time? I don't have enough vessels to do all four, so I need to scratch one option.
4. Since I'm still waiting for one secondary vessel to arrive, and I'm wanting to do malolactic on some of it, I haven't added SO2 to the full batch since fermentation began. There's barely any left now, like 4ppm. Am I playing with fire waiting? pH is very low, alcohol is high, and it's in an air-locked vessel. I'm thinking it should still have enough CO2 on top from fermentation, and nothing can get in from the air lock.

I know this is a lot and a long post, so thanks for reading this far. And thanks in advance for any insight.
 
I only have experience making wine at the home scale, so take my advice with a grain of salt, but:

1. Can't really advice on K-Carb, but with a TA of 10 g/L you have a wine that is tart but not *waay* out of line. I think your options to make a balanced wine with that acidity, if you don't want to use K-Carb, are a) do MLF, or b) backsweeten and make a semi-dry. I'm not sure if commercial wineries are allowed to backsweeten with sugar. We certainly can at a home scale but ideally you'd backsweeten with unfermented juice or arrest fermentation early
2. Up to you depending on what you're going for stylistically. Do you want creaminess and bready notes from the yeast? then age on lees for awhile. Are you after light, crisp fruitiness, then dump them
3. If I were you, I'd probably split in two - one half with MLF and aged with the lees (yeast sediment) like a Chardonnay, and the other with no lees aging, no MLF, but backsweetened to an off-dry or semi-sweet to balance the acidity (again not sure if you're allowed to use table sugar for backsweetening commercially)
4. You are probably pretty safe without adding SO2 for at least a week or two. The wine is pretty saturated with CO2 and the low pH makes it *somewhat* unlikely that unwanted spontaneous MLF would get going in that short timespan.
 
Thanks, great advice. I'm not opposed to using potassium carbonate, and I think I might lean toward that, rather than back-sweetening. We're not going to be able to sell this wine, so it's more about coming up with a procedure for next year when we are commercially licensed. I have K carb on hand, I just want to make sure I do it right. And I'm curious whether it indeed should have been added pre-fermentation, rather than post.
 
1. With the acidity so high to begin with, should I have added K carb before fermentation? I had one winemaker friend tell me to always wait until after, and another later tell me to always add it before.
The initial pH of 3.07 is on the low side, but not terrible. I favor the wait-n-see approach, so I would not have adjusted it.

2. I dumped the initial sediment from the must out before fermentation. In brewing, we'd call it a trub dump. Now that primary is over, do I need to dump the yeast sediment ASAP, or keep the wine on it? I'm confused about that.
Do you mean you let the juice settle, then dumped the initial sediment? That's fine -- with less solids, it will make a slightly lighter wine.

3. Do you think any of the options above for experimentation are a waste of time? I don't have enough vessels to do all four, so I need to scratch one option.
MLF is useful only if the malic acid is high. It does not touch tartaric.

I have no experience with La Crescent, but if Craig (@cmason1957) thinks it's a bad idea, I'd listen to him. An option is to try MLF on a few gallons to see what happens.

K carbonate can impart a chalky taste. Go light with additions, and go by taste, not TA or pH. Keep in mind it's far easier to add more than to take some out.

I backsweetened last fall's Vidal lightly, as Craig suggested, 1/4 cup sugar per 4 liters. The result is off-dry and very pleasing. I was targeting dry, but Mother Nature and Dionysus overruled me.

4. Since I'm still waiting for one secondary vessel to arrive, and I'm wanting to do malolactic on some of it, I haven't added SO2 to the full batch since fermentation began. There's barely any left now, like 4ppm. Am I playing with fire waiting? pH is very low, alcohol is high, and it's in an air-locked vessel. I'm thinking it should still have enough CO2 on top from fermentation, and nothing can get in from the air lock.
People let wine go months without SO2 when doing MLF, so your wine is in no danger. Your conditions make the wine better preserved than typical.
 
Thanks for the input, folks. Sorry I haven't replied, but we've taken your suggestions as valuable input and changed strategy a little. We still want to experiment this round. But instead of doing a large batch of MLF, we just pulled off about 15% into one of my old homebrew conicals to see to it affects the wine in a side by side.
The wine mellowed a little in the couple weeks after primary. pH has risen to about 3.3, and TA is still about 10.5. 71B was advertised as a yeast that reduced acid, and that seems to be true.

After tasting it, another winery owner friend of ours said he wouldn't make any adjustments. But he also suggested potentially backsweetening at bottling time, depending on where it lands, rather than changing anything before it's done aging. I imagine cold aging will drop the tartaric level even more, so it might end up just fine.

I added SO2 to the non MLF majority a couple weeks after primary was done, but only to about 20. It's interesting, winemaker81 inferred we'd be okay to go without SO2 for a while, while most resources I've found pushed it as soon as primary was over. Now, as a brewer, we'll always let the yeast go for a while after primary to clean up the garbage it produced. And since it's all sach cerv, it would make sense it would do the same for wine. Then I was listening to Jim Duran's podacst the other day, and he was interviewing a sparkling winemaker who said they only add SO2 at crush and right before bottling. They don't want to stop the yeast from doing its cleanup work, and adding SO2 basically freezes the progress of the wine, as far as the yeast is concerned.
 
It's interesting, winemaker81 inferred we'd be okay to go without SO2 for a while, while most resources I've found pushed it as soon as primary was over.
Consider that when doing MLF, adding K-meta will stop the MLB, so it's necessary to add K-meta later.

In that same vein, I was taught to get wine off the gross lees (fruit solids) ASAP. Yet winemakers in Burgundy and other places use Extended Maceration (EM) where the wine sets on the gross lees for up to 90 days.

Winemaking is a mass of contradictions where 2 opposing methods may both be valid.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top