David sent me a sample of your wine. It arrived yesterday! My wife thought it smells like maple but to me it was vanilla! Maybe even some butterscotch or caramel notes. The pH is higher than you expect from a “wine” so that’s different. As for the pecan wood, I would definitely not call it too much. It adds a nice finish but there isn’t the traditional oaky feel in the mouth. I like it, but like you said, It’s more of a novelty wine. I’m trying to think of what it would pair with. Probably something with a lighter flavor like fish.I have made maple wine several times. RiceGuy actually has a bottle of mine. We just happen to be at a wine competition yesterday in the Madison area. This bottle took home a blue ribbon from our peers.
Things I can tell you. 1- I don’t do a lot of testing for ph do I don’t know that one.
2- I do remember it being a slow fermentation. 6 weeks or so.
3- tasting notes. The nose is gonna be maple syrup. It has to fill the room. This one does. Taste. I used a pecan wood I toasted myself to ‘oak’ it. I might have over dons the wood. It’s pretty woodsy but it’s maple syrup. It comes from trees. Best flavor profile I can give you is it’s a lot like a cognac. Personally I like it but feel this is an acquired taste novelty wine.
If you’re ever heading to Madison look me up I can gift you a bottle.
My maple is still actively fermenting (sg about 1.010) so the CO2 messes with the taste. Take that into consideration for this comparison… At this point the color is identical. My pH is at 3.7, so with the CO2 it tastes a little sharper. Mine is very smokey tasting and I haven’t even oaked it yet, so I think that taste comes from the syrup, not your pecan wood. I think mine will definitely benefit from some oak for complexity and finish. I’ll keep a close watch on it though because I feel it could be easily overdone.
I’m saving the rest of the sample until mine is done fermenting so I can try this again.