Yep, totally makes sense.
First of all...it's not about me. It's about my wife and daughters.
They would prefer around 14% - 14.5% alcohol content, bigger mouthfeel, not watery, more fruit forward and reduced spicy-ness.
But, if I do what I've seen you do in order to upgrade your wine kit (i.e. add specific gravity by making it a 5 gallon kit, capitalizing and adding fruit) I think that the 1118 -- included in the kit -- might be the wrong yeast as it will likely go well beyond 14%. Maybe D254 or 71B?
I saw that you added blueberries to your Fontana Shiraz kit, did it add to the mouthfeel? I apologize but I wasn't able to find your commentary after the fact.
So, based upon my review of many of the comments on this thread, I'm thinking that I should add fruit of some kind, reduce the volume of the kit some (maybe not down to 5 gallons) keeping the starting S.G. at or below 1.100 and use a different yeast...leaning toward the D254.
Thoughts?