I have the 18" Weber Smokey Mountain and love it. It's fairly easy to control the temp, especially on long burns. But it's not "set it and forget it" like the Traeger. My son has a Traeger and he can throw something on at 10 pm, go to bed and it's ready the next morning. BUT .... the pellets don't give you the authentic charcoal and wood flavor like the WSM. He recently made smoked salmon using my recipe and after 12 hours at 180 it was nowhere as dark or as flavorful as what I turn out. I enjoy the hands-on approach where I have to check the temperature occasionally and adjust the vents once in a while.OK all you gourmet chefs out there, I'm getting tired of seeing all this delicious looking food. I know this is going to be a personal choice thing but as I mentioned in other posts I have a bottom of the barrel stick smoker that I can't regulate the temperature. I visited my brother last and he has a Traeger pellet smoker. We did a pork shoulder and a brisket and both turned out wonderful with little to no monitoring. I've heard so many good things about the ceramic smokers but this Traeger was so easy. Both of these though seem to take some of the fun out of it and I was also considering a better quality stick unit. I also know a person that has an electric unit that has a door and shelved that said he would not use anything else. Let me have it, open to any comments.
Simple choice. Do you want to cook on "real" wood or sawdust?
Do you want something with moving parts (auger/motor) that will jam if the pellets get any moisture on them (does it rain where you live?) Do you like troubleshooting electronic circuit boards (and or replacing them)?
Do you want to rely on something that has moving parts, electronics for a big family cookout where you have to deliver the goods and it stops working halfway through the cook........
Or do you want to set it and forget it?
There are exactly two types of pellet grills. Those that have broken down........
And those that will.
Weber SmokeFire
Simple choice. Do you want to cook on "real" wood or sawdust?
Do you want something with moving parts (auger/motor) that will jam if the pellets get any moisture on them (does it rain where you live?) Do you like troubleshooting electronic circuit boards (and or replacing them)?
Do you want to rely on something that has moving parts, electronics for a big family cookout where you have to deliver the goods and it stops working halfway through the cook........
View attachment 67277
View attachment 67278
Or do you want to set it and forget it?
View attachment 67279
There are exactly two types of pellet grills. Those that have broken down........
And those that will.
Don't get him started!Mike, it appears you on the fence with this as much as I am! LOL!
A nice 5-star dinner right there.Last nights dinner. Baked Halibut, Alaskan Salmon served with steamed broccoli and Mac-n-Cheese with gouda and aged white cheddar........
View attachment 67332
Today is our anniversary. Original plan we were going to be in Jamaica, but due to Covid we pushed it out a year. So..surf and turf with some of her favorites. Lobster bisque soup, mashed potatoes, lobster tail, angus tenderloin sous vide. We also made macarons for the 1st time and they turned out pretty good. All with WE selection Chardonnay View attachment 67449View attachment 67450View attachment 67451
Looks like someone went out to Bennihanna (or similar)?
Who doesn't love it when you go freezer diving and you come up with a 2lb Beef Tenderloin!
Enter your email address to join: