What's for Dinner?

Winemaking Talk - Winemaking Forum

Help Support Winemaking Talk - Winemaking Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Mrs. WM81 requested chicken pot pie, so that was dinner last night. I've never been fond of the dish, as the commercial ones are all crust with a tiny bit of bland filling. This is my third time making a pot pie in the last few years, so I researched recipes and got one off AllRecipes.

I followed the recipe exactly, except for changing everything. 🤣

It was useful for proportions, but any recipe that says to boil chicken and throw the stock out is NOT to be followed.

Fried the chicken, caramelized shallots, sauted the vegetables (carrots & potato), and made the gravy in one pan. Assembled it in a 9" cake pan, not a pie plate, so each piece is a meal. I'm going to make it again in a couple of weeks, refining what I did this time.

pot pie 2.jpg

Getting the first piece out picture perfect quality doesn't happen ... but Mrs. WM81 said it was the best one she's ever had. [To be fair, all she's had before this is commercial frozen ones and my first 2 attempts, which were still better than frozen.]

pot pie 1.jpg

Preserving flavors by making everything in one pan (do one thing, remove it, start the next ...) and caramelizing the shallots is the big win.
 
It was useful for proportions, but any recipe that says to boil chicken and throw the stock out is NOT to be followed.
The thing I love about recipes is that you don't need to prove your cooking skills to post a recipe. Sometimes it is glaringly obvious they are absent within the instruction. Other times you have to figure it out the hard way.

If you want to wind me up, show me a mushroom soup recipe with a can of mushroom in the ingredients. You will get a fun response. 🤣

Reviews are definitely my favorite part. I didn't have A.B,or C and I wasn't going to simmer for 2 hours. I put it in the microwave for 2 minutes and the meat was SO tough.

This recipe sucks!

I have also only made this a few time over many many years. Better than frozen, but I never dazzled myself. The one thing I did get right was presentation. If you make it again a cheap ramekin set for individual servings makes it fun!

Next time save me a piece, would ya?😁
 
The thing I love about recipes is that you don't need to prove your cooking skills to post a recipe. Sometimes it is glaringly obvious they are absent within the instruction. Other times you have to figure it out the hard way.
This recipe has mostly 5 star reviews. Which makes me question the reviewers.

I consider that tastes vary. I know one person who cooks with no seasoning -- her food is as bland as can be. Her taste buds work, but she doesn't want food that has taste. I'm not understanding that.

The thing is that the recipe I started with was exactly that, a starting point. I read the negative reviews -- a couple were laughable, but three pointed out what to me are glaring problems with the recipe. Then I applied my experience in cooking, and produced a really good result. Unfortunately, some of it was "winging it", so I need to do it again and do better measurement so I can record it.

Side note -- when I was just out of college (university), the woman I was dating lamented that her grandmother died, and with her a large chunk of the family recipes that existed only in her head. I realized how many recipes existed only in my mom's head, so for the next 3 years, we scheduled time on weekends to make recipes. She cooked while I measured and recorded. When my mom departed the mortal coil 15 years later, all her recipes were safely recorded. I printed books to distribute within the family.

I make it a point to record the recipes I either like or invent. My sons are contributing their recipes, and my plan for next Christmas is to print books through Lulu to send to various family members.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top