This recipe has mostly 5 star reviews. Which makes me question the reviewers.
I consider that tastes vary. I know one person who cooks with no seasoning -- her food is as bland as can be. Her taste buds work, but she doesn't want food that has taste. I'm not understanding that.
The thing is that the recipe I started with was exactly that, a starting point. I read the negative reviews -- a couple were laughable, but three pointed out what to me are glaring problems with the recipe. Then I applied my experience in cooking, and produced a really good result. Unfortunately, some of it was "winging it", so I need to do it again and do better measurement so I can record it.
Side note -- when I was just out of college (university), the woman I was dating lamented that her grandmother died, and with her a large chunk of the family recipes that existed only in her head. I realized how many recipes existed only in my mom's head, so for the next 3 years, we scheduled time on weekends to make recipes. She cooked while I measured and recorded. When my mom departed the mortal coil 15 years later, all her recipes were safely recorded. I printed books to distribute within the family.
I make it a point to record the recipes I either like or invent. My sons are contributing their recipes, and my plan for next Christmas is to print books through Lulu to send to various family members.