My brother conducted a bourbon tasting for my son & me. From left to right, the bottles are: Johnny Walker Blue, Four Roses, Eagle Rare, Sazerac Rye, Old Ezra 7, Old Forester 1910, Bluegrass, Woodford Reserve, Buffalo Trace.
He threw in a Sazerac Rye as a ringer, and we tasted Johnny Walker Blue afterward, as it's not in the same class as bourbon.
The results were surprising. Old Ezra 7 and Old Forester 1910 were highly rated in several articles, and we all disliked them.
Bluegrass as next -- it's claim to fame is it's made from blue corn. It smelled and tasted like tortilla chips. Ugh!
I've had Eagle Rare before, and was not impressed, and we all agreed it was #4 from the bottom.
Four Roses was my brother's go-to bourbon, but it's been replaced.
The last 2 (Woodford Reserve, Buffalo Trace) were the tough ones. My brother prefers Buffalo Trace, my son prefers Woodford, and I went back-n-forth, with no clear winner.
View attachment 91226