Jgmann67, I am pleased to tell you that you can keep Williams Brewing Company on your list. Here is the response that I received today (and I did not ask that they replace the kit, I only asked if they could tell me what happened and if anyone else had had this problem). This is excellent customer service:
"I can definitely agree with you that the color looks too light in the carboy on the left. In years past there have been occasional cans of concentrate from our supplier that have been lighter than normal in color. Our guess was that they accidentally sent us some other variety in our shipment. That is my only guess with your Malbec kit from us. We haven’t heard of anything happening recently though. I am hoping it is an isolated incident.
I am going to send you another Malbec kit, let us know if this one has any problems, when you put it into the fermenter.
As for the lighter colored stuff, I cannot say what type of juice it is but if it tastes good it may be worth finishing and bottling rather than dumping.
Sorry for any inconvenience,
Tom
William's Brewing Customer Support
2088 Burroughs Avenue
San Leandro CA 94577
[email protected]
www.williamsbrewing.com"