FlexTank instead of oak barrel...really interesting

[semenn]

In my understanding, a flex (plastic) tank does not replace a barrel, but is an essential equipment in the initial stage of winemaking.

 

[ibglowin]

You might need to rethink things then.

In my understanding, a flex (plastic) tank does not replace a barrel, but is an essential equipment in the initial stage of winemaking.

 

[semenn]

Most likely, I do not see the proper benefit from having the processes of an oak barrel transported to an artificial environment. But everything can change with time. So I'm talking about my opinion on the use of plastic tanks at the moment.

 

[ibglowin]

Yes! Good way to phrase this exchange I would say.

So I'm talking about my opinion on the use of plastic tanks at the moment.

 

[sdelli]

We can compare the process of micro oxidation from flex tanks to barrels. But that is only part of the equation. I do not believe you can achieve in today's technology the duplication of a good oak barrel with cubes or sticks..... I use both all the time.... They are different.

 

[crushday]

Interesting read and non-biased study by Daniel Pambianchi:

https://www.techniquesinhomewinemak...d-in-a-flextank-vs-a-two-year-old-oak-barrel/

 

[ibglowin]

Talk about an reviving an old thread!

Actual results here:

https://techniquesinhomewinemaking....n a Flextank vs Oak Barrel (13-24 months).pdf

 

[crushday]

"Talk about an reviving an old thread!" - @ibglowin

I know...lol. I did my own experiment last year with favorable results. I just bought four more (had one) Dexter 50 maturation tanks... They have a small thumb print for the volume and the resulting wine is different from my barrels but I wouldn't go so far as to say better.

 

[Bmd2k1]

"Talk about an reviving an old thread!" - @ibglowin

I know...lol. I did my own experiment last year with favorable results. I just bought four more (had one) Dexter 50 maturation tanks... They have a small thumb print for the volume and the resulting wine is different from my barrels but I wouldn't go so far as to say better.

Curious to hear more about your results!

Cheers ✌