My main thought here is this, does residual sugar taste different than backsweeteing? I think that real sugar, such as cane or beet, tastes very similar. Would that mean that residual sugar is the same? Or is there another process that makes the difference by going dry? The only thing I can think of, is when yeasts die slowly, off flavors can arise. Furthermore, is it possible to get 13-14% abv and be semisweet (1.010+) without adding sugar? I think wine that stays under 12% will typically be better than a wine that is 13-14%, so if we are comparing these two, they need to be nearly the exact same sweetness AND ABV. Otherwise, it's apples and oranges. Speaking of, fruit wines would be different, because you have to add sugar up front to get enough abv. So for this comparison, lets just say only grape wines. Does anyone know of a grape wine that can be found as non-backsweetened and backsweetened with the same or very close in both abv and sugar?
As far as filtering, plate filters are nice, but I'm not sure how many wineries use them. They are not cheap, nor work well with smaller batches.