I disagree. Most of the Southern Rhone I like are 40% to 75% Grenache. IME the most common blends in Southern Rhone are at least 50% Grenache.Grenache is mostly good for blends it always falls flat on its face in pure Grenache wines it lacks good tannins it lacks good acidity has poor color potential and tends to suffer from a few faults in winemaking.
Are CA Grenache different from Rhone? Undoubtedly.
Earlier this month my son & I bottled our 2022 wines: barrel aged Grenache, barrel aged Tempranillo, and glass aged Mourvedre / Petite Sirah / Syrah (Rhone blend). All grapes are CA grown.
We conducted 2 tastings, one with Tempranillo and the Rhone blend, and the second with Grenache with the Rhone blend.
For the Tempranillo, we tasted the following blends with Rhone blend: 0%, 5%, 10%, 15%. We really liked the pure Tempranillo, but also liked the 5% blend. The 10% and 15% blends drowned the Tempranillo. Our decision was to bottle 3 cases of Tempranillo and 4 cases of 5% blend.
Then we tested the Grenache: 0%, 5%, 10%, 15%, and 20%. The winners were 0% and 20%, so we made 25% and 30% blends.
The 0% is a winner. Make no mistake, it's a lighter colored and bodied wine, which was gentle up front and lingered in the aftertaste. We bottled 3 cases.
The other winner was the 25%. The 30% overwhelmed the Grenache. The 5%-20% were lacking in some way, while the 25% was a great balance -- a REALLY heavy duty red up front with lots of tobacco, fading into a long Grenache finish in the nose and back of the throat. We bottled 6.5 cases of this plus 1/2 case of a 50/50 blend. A year from now we'll see how things age.
I expected we'd bottle the Tempranillo "as is" and the Grenache in the 35% range. Instead of 2 wines we bottled 4, and the blends were different from what I expected.