OK Joe...the bad
Did a cellarcraft Chardonnay...reduced the volume and used the zest of two grapefruits. That was a bigger kit and I don't think the volume should have been reduced. The wine is pretty full bodied, almost thick. WAY too much grapefruit zest. Even after a year and half this wine still has an unpleasant wang to it from the grapefruit. I've learned to decant and add about 1/4 bottle of water...that gets the wine about where it would have been if made to six gallons. Still a lot of citrus. Closing note, the store owner told me this was an older kit and gave me a great price....but I don't think the kit was bad. Nor were your tweaks. This kit is one that should not have been reduce and I learned zest is very powerful stuff.
A Winexpert Pinot Grigo...I added a half pint of citrus extract made from Myers lemons and Clemintine zest. You would think I would learn...ZEST IS VERY POWERFUL STUFF, but noooo! Still new, bottled in Oct....over ice half and half with Sprite it is a really good wine cooler.
the good
Almost every other kit I have done. The Fontana Malbec is simply very good. Folks rave on that on one. Fourth batch with added canned cherries, plums, and blackberries is bulk aging with a honeycomb cherry stick right now...may be the best one yet.
The mist kits to 5 gallons, half the Fpack in the primary, SG bumbed up....all lip smackers.
The Fontana and Winexpert Pinot Nior with added tannins, reduced volume, and blackberry Fpack are very nice. One lady said the Pinot was too full bodied but tasted great. The fontana is over a year old, the Winexpert is much newer....Fontana is better, but that could just be the time factor.
Have a Fontana Sangiovese/Canaiolo Chianti Style in secondary, reduced to 5.5 gallon, it still look full bodied, extra tannins in primary. Life caught up with me and I didn't add anything else. Racked to secondary after 14 days and don't think I will add anything else it tasted really good at first racking.
Next two kits are the bigger Winexpert Selection kits with skins. Plan on extending primary to at least 14 days, perhaps 30...then again I may just follow directions!
The cheap kits are allowing my bigger Eclipse kits to rest mostly untouched while drinking these tweaked kits early. That was the plan I stole from some else on this forum and it seems to be working well. I do really enjoy the tweaking. To the point is is painful to not tweak, not to mention boring!